Two museums in China about the Cultural Revolution show very different versions of history

May 16, Published on Quartz

Off to be “educated”: an exhibit at the Jianchuan Museum Cluster. (Briony Lin)

Judging by China’s state-controlled media, you might not even be aware that today marks the 50th anniversary of the start of the Cultural Revolution. On May 16, 1966, Communist Party leader Mao Zedong launched a 10-year campaign in the name of combating capitalism. It is estimated that millions of people died from the political violence that swept across the country (or from suicide).

But whereas state media is keeping quiet about this sensitive period in Chinese history, two very different museums—and the state they’re in—speak volumes about the Cultural Revolution and how it’s viewed today. One museum honors and commemorates those who lost their lives, and is neglected and little visited. The other one is also trying to preserve history, but in a way that’s more palatable to today’s Communist Party—and is thriving.

The Cultural Revolution Museum in Shantou

On a recent spring day, a “Mr. Wong”—he declined to give his full name or profession—was one of the few people wandering amid the plaques and re-created tombstones at the Cultural Revolution Museum in Shantou. The museum is the only public memorial in China commemorating the victims who died or suffered grave harm from the atrocities of the decade-long period that began 50 years ago.

The gate of Shantou’s Pagoda Park, home to the Cultural Revolution Museum. The statue is of Yu Xiqu, a former local county magistrate who suffered intense abuse during the period.(Briony Lin)

Wong said he had visited the museum numerous times. On this day, he brought along his 76-year-old father, who traveled from his hometown in Shanxi, over 1,000 miles away.

“We must remember history,” the elder Wong said of his first visit to the museum. “The younger generation doesn’t really care, while only a handful of older people would come here.”

The Cultural Revolution Museum in Shantou.(Briony Lin)

In the lead-up to the 50th anniversary, the government banned activities or signs of remembrances of those traumatic years. At the Shantou museum, the exhibits were covered by the Chinese Communist Party’s propaganda banners and posters, starting earlier this month.

This wall near the museum lists 300-plus crimes of which people were accused, among them being a “counter-revolutionary revisionist” or “bourgeois element.”(Briony Lin)

Located in the outskirts of Shantou, a southeastern port city in China, the museum opened with much fanfare in January 2005. Today, it is a very quiet place. At the entrance, the arch marked with “Cultural Revolution Museum” is draped with a banner reading “Socialist Core Values Promotional Activity.”

Some of the monuments are for those who lost their lives in the persecutions.(Briony Lin)

But there are signs of visitors who have refused to forget. Flowers, now withering under the sun, lay at the tombstones for the deceased. Shells of sunflower seeds litter the floor of Sian Tower, a stately structure at the center of the museum.

The Sian Tower.(Briony Lin)

The museum was created by Peng Qian, the former deputy mayor of Shantou and a veteran member of the Communist Party. Born in 1932, he witnessed the Cultural Revolution first-hand. When he visited the pagoda park in Shantou’s Chenghai district in 1996, he was shocked to find over 70 little-known graves (including some mass graves) of those who were persecuted and died during the Cultural Revolution. He started planning a more proper memorial.

When the museum opened to the public in 2005, it received widespread media coverage. The opening ceremony was attended by luminaries such as Feng Jicai, vice president of the Federation of Literary and Art Circles. The many donors included Hong Kong tycoon Li Ka-shing, who sent inscriptions and 300,000 yuan.

This wall near the park entrance features a line across the top reading, “Draw a lesson from history and do not let the tragedy of Cultural Revolution repeat itself.”(Briony Lin)

After that, Peng held an annual memorial ceremony for those who died during the Cultural Revolution. The ceremonies stopped in 2014, a year after the museum’s bank account for receiving donations was closed, and some exhibits went missing.

About a year ago, Peng handed over the museum to the local government, citing his old age.

“I haven’t seen Peng for a long time. I can’t get in touch with him,” said Chen Zhaomin, one of the founders still in charge of the museum.

As the Wongs lingered among the artifacts, four boisterous young men nearby watched Hurry Up, Brother, a popular Chinese entertainment show, on an iPad. There were no attendants or other visitors in sight.

Repeated calls to Du Xuping, the director of the museum, were not answered.

The Jianchuan Museum Cluster

Near Chengdu, the Jianchuan Museum Cluster also marks the Cultural Revolution. But compared to the Shantou memorial, it sticks to the government’s propaganda line and makes relatively few mentions of the period’s atrocities.

The front gate of the Jianchuan Museum Cluster. On the four pillars its says: “Remember war for peace. Remember lessons for the future. Remember disasters for serenity. Remember folk customs for heritage.”(Briony Lin)

Also unlike its Shantou counterpart, it’s thriving. Consisting of six buildings and thousands of artifacts from the period, it receives over 100,000 visitors a month, according to its promotion office.

Opened in 2005, it’s the largest museum complex in mainland China, with 27 venues stretching across 1,500 acres of land.

Stacks of newspaper articles from the old days are on display in these museums. Washbasins and cups painted with quotations of Mao are exhibited behind glass showcases. Photos, propaganda posters, and stories of educated youths hang on the wall.

Mugs with quotations from chairman Mao.(Briony Lin)

Another complex in the cluster is filled with thousands of badges engraved with portraits of Mao. Words like “loyal” and “long live Chairman Mao” fill the rooms. On one wall, four giant portraits of Mao, composed of red badges, look on.

Portraits of Chairman Mao made by hundreds of badges from the Cultural Revolution.(Briony Lin)

In another building, hundreds of clocks painted with propaganda pictures and quotations of Mao (including “serve the people”) occupy the wall. The clock hands strike the hours in unison.

Beating in unison.(Briony Lin)

Established and funded by Fan Jianchuan, a 59-year-old Sichuanese property developer and collector, the museum is expanding, with new venues under construction.

The museums are divided into four themes: the Anti-Japanese War, the Cultural Revolution, major earthquakes, and folk culture. Over 100,000 Cultural Revolution exhibits show life under Mao’s rule.

The official museum website describes one set of the exhibits as reflecting “the glory of the mission, the devotion and effort of the youths, and the cohesive force and impetus they produced, which are important parts of the spiritual wealth of our nation.”

Building such a museum in China is a tricky task. In light of sensitivities, the museum put up posters of Chinese president Xi Jinping.(Briony Lin)

The publicity director of the museum cluster declined to talk about its exhibits on the Cultural Revolution. “This topic is relatively sensitive,” he said. “The museum cluster needs to continue to operate. If something went wrong, there will be a huge problem.”

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: